Immigration Law

IRCC Refused Your Application? Common Reasons and What to Do Next

IRCC Refused Your Application? Common Reasons and What to Do Next

A refusal letter from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) is stressful, and the next few days matter more than most people realise. Some of the ways to respond have very short time limits, and some of the most common reactions, such as reapplying straight away with the same documents, often lead to the same result.

This guide explains the most common reasons IRCC refuses applications, including refusals for not providing the information or documents IRCC asked for, and what each of your options is afterwards. It is general information for people applying from inside or outside Canada. It is not legal advice about your file, because the right step depends on the exact words in your letter.

Time limits are short. To challenge a refusal at the Federal Court by judicial review, you generally have 15 days from the day you are notified if the decision was made in Canada, and 60 days if it was made outside Canada. Count from the date you received the decision, not the date you decide to act. A reconsideration request to IRCC does not stop that clock. If you are already past the deadline, there may still be a remedy: see the section on asking the court to extend the time, below.

Start here: the first three things to do

  1. Read the whole letter, then read it again. Find the exact reasons given, the sections of the law mentioned, and any dates. The reasons decide your options.
  2. Write down the date you received it and count forward 15 and 60 days. Put both dates in your calendar, or use our free deadline calculator, which works out the dates for refusals, refugee decisions, removal orders and IRCC letters and gives you a calendar file with reminders.
  3. Do not send a new application or a long explanation yet. A second application that repeats the same weaknesses is usually refused for the same reasons, and anything you say now can be compared with what you said before.

What kind of decision did you actually get?

People use the word “refusal” for several different things. The difference changes what you can do.

  • Refused. An officer reviewed your application and decided not to approve it. The letter gives reasons. This is the decision you can challenge in court.
  • Rejected or returned as incomplete. The application was never assessed because something required was missing, such as a signature, a form or a fee. This is not a refusal on the merits. You can usually fix the problem and submit again.
  • Procedural fairness letter (PFL). The officer has a concern and is giving you a chance to respond before deciding. This is not a refusal yet, and the response deadline in the letter is firm. See our guide to what to do with a procedural fairness letter.
  • A request for more information or documents. IRCC asks you to send something by a date. If you do not, the application can be refused. This is covered in detail below.
  • No decision at all. A long delay is a different problem, with a different remedy. See the section on delays below.

Free tool: Why was my application refused?

Pick the reason in your refusal letter and see what it usually means, what officers look at, the evidence that helps, how the Federal Court has dealt with it, and your options. Nothing is uploaded, saved or sent.

Explore the reasons

The most common reasons IRCC refuses applications

1. The officer was not satisfied you will leave Canada

For visitor visas, study permits and work permits, this is the most common ground. The officer decides that you have not shown you will leave Canada at the end of your authorized stay (the rules behind this are section 179(b), section 216(1)(b) and section 200(1)(b) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations). The letter usually lists reasons such as your travel history, your family ties in your home country, your employment or the purpose of your visit.

These refusals are often written in standard wording. A strong response does not repeat that you will leave. It supplies evidence the officer did not have or did not weigh.

2. Funds are insufficient or unclear

The officer is not satisfied you can pay for your stay, your tuition or your return. A bank statement with a large recent deposit and no explanation is a classic cause. So are statements that do not match the income you declared.

3. The purpose of the trip or the study plan is not convincing

For study permits especially, officers look at whether the program makes sense for your background and goals. A study plan that reads like a template, or a program that does not fit your history, leads to refusals.

4. You did not provide the information or documents IRCC required (section 16)

Section 16(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act requires a person who applies to answer truthfully all questions put to them and to produce the evidence and documents the officer reasonably requires. When IRCC asks for something and it does not arrive, or arrives late or incomplete, the officer can decide the application on what is in front of them. In practice that usually means a refusal.

This kind of refusal happens in several ways:

  • The request was sent to your online account or email and you did not see it, or it went to a spam folder.
  • The deadline passed while you were gathering a document, such as a police certificate, a medical result or a reference letter, from an office that was slow.
  • You sent part of what was requested and the officer treated the rest as missing.
  • You sent documents, but the officer decided they were not sufficient: not the right kind of evidence, out of date, unclear, or not enough to answer the concern.
  • You sent documents but did not answer the question the officer actually asked.

If you receive a request, act on it quickly.

  • Note the exact deadline and what is being asked for. Answer every item.
  • If a document will take longer than the deadline allows, write to IRCC before the deadline, say what you are waiting for and when it will arrive, and send everything else on time. Keep proof of the request and the date you sent it.
  • Send what you can, with a short explanation, rather than nothing.
  • Check your online account and spam folder regularly while an application is pending.

If you were refused because you did not provide what was requested, or because what you sent was found not sufficient, the best response depends on why. If the request never reached you, or the deadline was unreasonably short given what was asked, there may be grounds to challenge the decision as unfair or unreasonable. If the information was simply not sent, or the evidence was thin and can be strengthened, a new application with the complete package is often faster and cheaper than a court case, but you should check first whether the refusal also raised credibility or misrepresentation concerns, because those change the picture.

5. Misrepresentation

If the officer finds that you gave false information or left out something important, the application can be refused and you can be barred from applying for five years under section 40 of the Act. This is among the most serious findings in immigration law, and it can follow an honest mistake as well as a deliberate one. A five-year ban can come from something as simple as answering one question wrongly, for example answering “no” to “Have you ever been refused a visa or permit to Canada or any other country?” when you had been refused before. IRCC can often find earlier refusals in its own records and through information sharing with other countries, so an untrue or careless answer is easy to uncover. If your letter mentions section 40 or misrepresentation, read our guide to the five-year ban under section 40 before you do anything else.

6. Inadmissibility

Criminal history (including offences abroad), health conditions that could cause excessive demand on services, security concerns, and earlier immigration violations can each make a person inadmissible. These refusals often have their own routes, such as a record suspension, rehabilitation or a temporary resident permit, so the right path depends on the specific ground.

7. The program requirements were not met

For permanent residence streams, officers refuse where the language results, education, work experience, proof of funds or relationship evidence do not meet the program rules. In family sponsorship, an officer may decide the relationship is not genuine or was entered into mainly to obtain status.

Free tool: Immigration Deadline Calculator

Not sure of your dates? Choose what happened, enter the date, and see your deadlines for judicial review, appeals and IRCC letters, with source references.

Check my deadlines

Your options after a refusal

Reapply with a stronger application

Often the right choice, especially for visitor, study and work applications where there is no waiting period. A new application should answer every reason in the letter with evidence. It should also report the earlier refusal honestly, because every form asks about previous refusals and an untrue answer can create a misrepresentation problem that is worse than the original refusal.

Ask the officer to reconsider

IRCC accepts reconsideration requests through a web form, but reconsideration is discretionary. Nobody has a legal right to it, IRCC can choose to reopen your file or choose not to, and there is no set deadline for IRCC to respond. It tends to be used for clear mistakes, such as an officer overlooking a document that was submitted. Importantly, sending a reconsideration request does not pause the time limit for judicial review, so do not let it use up the days you have.

Get the officer’s notes

The notes in IRCC’s file (known as GCMS notes) show how the officer reasoned and often give a much fuller picture than the letter. You can request them through an Access to Information and Privacy (ATIP) request. Processing can take weeks or longer, so if the judicial review deadline is close, do not wait for them. If the case goes to court, the file the court sees includes the officer’s notes.

Apply for judicial review at the Federal Court

Judicial review does not ask the court to decide whether you should be approved. It asks whether the decision was unreasonable or made unfairly. Examples include an officer ignoring evidence, reaching a conclusion the evidence cannot support, giving reasons that do not explain the result, or not giving you a fair chance to respond to a concern. You need the court’s permission (called “leave”) to proceed, and leave is not guaranteed. If the court sets the decision aside, the usual result is that a different officer looks at the application again. It is not an automatic approval.

The time limits are the ones in the box at the top: 15 days for decisions made in Canada and 60 days for decisions made outside Canada, counted from when you were notified. Our overview of how judicial review works explains the steps.

We offer judicial review of immigration decisions at an affordable flat fee that is quoted in writing before we start, so you know the full cost up front.

If you missed the deadline: asking the court to extend the time

Missing the deadline does not always end the matter. The Federal Court has the power to extend the time for filing a judicial review. It is not automatic, and you have to get over that hurdle first, before the court will look at whether the decision was wrong. You must give a sufficient and cogent reason for the delay, and the court applies a four-part test, set out in Canada (Attorney General) v. Hennelly, 1999 CanLII 8190 (FCTAD):

  • Continuing intention. You intended to challenge the decision throughout, from the time you received it, and not only from the day you found a lawyer.
  • Potential merit. There is an arguable case that the decision was unreasonable or unfair.
  • No prejudice. The delay has not unfairly harmed the other side.
  • A reasonable explanation. You can explain the delay, for the whole of the period you were late.

Circumstances such as serious illness or never receiving the decision can help, but only if you can prove them with dates, documents and messages, and show what you did to act as soon as you could. If you are close to the deadline or already past it, speak to a lawyer straight away. Every extra day is something you will have to explain.

Appeal, where the law allows one

Most immigration refusals cannot be appealed. A few can. For example, a sponsor whose family sponsorship application was refused generally has a right of appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division, and the time limit for that is short. There is an important exception: where the refusal was based on misrepresentation, the sponsor cannot appeal unless the person being sponsored is their spouse, common-law partner or child. Refugee claim decisions have their own appeal route with its own deadline. The refusal letter usually tells you if an appeal is available, and it is worth checking the same day you receive it.

If you are waiting and there has been no decision

A very long wait is not a refusal, but it can be just as frustrating. Start by checking IRCC’s published processing times for your application type and by using the status and webform channels. If the application has been outstanding far beyond normal times and IRCC has given no good explanation, the Federal Court can be asked for an order of mandamus. That is an order requiring IRCC to make a decision. It does not order IRCC to approve, and the court looks at whether the delay is unreasonable and unexplained. Our guide to IRCC delays and mandamus explains when that is possible and what to do first.

Mistakes that make refusals worse

  • Reapplying within days with the same documents and no new explanation.
  • Telling a different story from the earlier application.
  • Missing an IRCC deadline because the message went to a spam folder.
  • Answering “no” to the question about previous refusals to Canada or any other country when there was one. That alone can lead to a five-year ban for misrepresentation.
  • Waiting for the officer’s notes while the court deadline runs out.
  • Relying on someone who is not a lawyer or a licensed immigration consultant. Only those people, and a few other regulated professionals, can represent you for a fee.

Frequently asked questions

Can I reapply right away after a refusal?

In most cases yes, because there is generally no waiting period. The exception is a finding of misrepresentation, which carries a five-year bar. Whether you should reapply right away is a separate question. A new application that does not deal with the reasons for the first one is likely to be refused again.

What does a refusal under section 16 of the Act mean?

It means the officer decided you did not answer questions truthfully or did not produce the evidence and documents that were reasonably required. Often it is because a request from IRCC was not answered in full or in time. The first step is to find out exactly what was requested, when and how it was sent, and whether you responded.

I missed IRCC’s deadline to send documents. Is my application lost?

Not always. If the decision has not been made, write to IRCC immediately with what you have and an explanation. If it has been refused, the options are a new application with the full package or, in some situations, a challenge to the decision. Act quickly, because the court time limits are short.

How long do I have to challenge a refusal in court?

Generally 15 days if the decision was made in Canada and 60 days if it was made outside Canada, counted from the day you were notified. If you are late, you must ask the court to extend the time and satisfy a four-part test (continuing intention, potential merit, no prejudice and a reasonable explanation for the delay), so do not rely on it.

Does a successful judicial review mean I get approved?

No. The usual result is that the application goes back to a different officer for a new decision. That is still valuable, particularly where the first decision overlooked important evidence, but the outcome of the new decision is not guaranteed.

Do I need the officer’s notes before I can apply for judicial review?

No. If the deadline is close, you can file without them. The notes form part of the record the court receives later.

Will a refusal affect my future applications?

Yes. You must disclose previous refusals on later forms, and the earlier file is available to the next officer. A well prepared application that addresses the first refusal directly is much more likely to succeed than one that ignores it. Answer the question about previous refusals fully and honestly, for Canada and for any other country, because a wrong answer can itself lead to a five-year ban.

What is the difference between a refusal and a rejection?

A refusal is a decision on the merits, with reasons. A rejection or return means the application was incomplete and was not assessed. You can usually correct it and send it again.

Is it worth getting a lawyer for a refusal?

That depends on the reasons and on what is at stake. A short review of your letter can show whether the best step is a stronger new application, a request to the officer, or judicial review, and whether any deadline is about to pass.

Free 30-minute consultation

Refused, or received a letter from IRCC? Do not wait.

We will read your letter with you, check the deadlines, and tell you which options are realistic, including judicial review at an affordable flat fee.

Book a free consultationSend us your details

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Immigration rules and time limits change, and your own file may differ. Written by Livingstone Law Professional Corporation, Toronto.

Legal Disclaimer: This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article does not create a solicitor-client relationship. Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results. This website does not constitute legal advice. A solicitor-client relationship requires a signed retainer agreement. For advice specific to your situation, please book a consultation.
Livingstone Law Professional Corporation

Ontario-regulated law firm acting in Immigration Law and 17 areas of law across the GTA. Dual-qualified in Canada and Nigeria.

Book Free Consultation →