Immigration Law

IRCC Delays: When Can the Federal Court Order a Decision? (Mandamus)

Waiting a long time for IRCC to decide an application is stressful, and it can cost real things: a job offer that expires, a family kept apart, a permit that runs out. Most delays end without any court involvement. When they do not, the Federal Court can be asked to order IRCC to make a decision. This guide explains when that is possible, what it can and cannot achieve, and what to do first.

It is general information and not legal advice about your file. Whether a delay is unreasonable depends on the type of application, the published processing time and the reasons for the wait.

Mandamus orders a decision, not an approval. A court cannot tell IRCC to approve your application. At most it can order IRCC to decide it. The decision can still be a refusal, so the question is whether you want the decision made now.

What is mandamus?

Mandamus is a court order that requires a public official to carry out a duty they are legally bound to perform. In immigration, an officer must process and decide the applications that are properly before them. If IRCC has not done so for an unreasonable time and has not given a good reason, a Federal Court judge can order that the decision be made, and can set a time limit for it.

It is brought as an application to the Federal Court. In immigration matters it generally needs the court’s permission, called leave, just as a judicial review of a refusal does.

Is your delay long enough to matter?

There is no single number of months. Start with the processing time IRCC publishes for your type of application, and compare the time you have waited. A wait that is only slightly longer than the published time is rarely enough. A wait that is well past it, with no explanation, may be.

The court has asked three questions in delay cases, drawn from Conille v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration):

  • Has the delay been longer than the nature of the process requires, at first look?
  • Is the applicant responsible for the delay, or is IRCC?
  • Has IRCC given a satisfactory reason for the delay?

More broadly, courts apply a set of requirements for mandamus that come from Apotex Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General). In plain terms, you must show that:

  • IRCC has a legal duty to act, and owes it to you.
  • You have a clear right to the decision: you have met the conditions, you have asked for it, and IRCC has refused or has delayed unreasonably.
  • There is no other adequate remedy.
  • An order would have practical value, and the balance of convenience favours making it.

Reasons for delay the court may accept

A delay is not unreasonable just because it is long. The court may accept that a delay is justified where:

  • Security or background checks are in progress, and IRCC can show they are ongoing. The court is more patient with this reason than with others, but not without limit.
  • The applicant caused the delay, for example by not giving requested documents or changing the application.
  • Other checks, such as medical or police clearances, depend on third parties.

A general statement that the file is “in process” is usually not an explanation. Specific, current reasons carry more weight.

What to do before going to court

  1. Check the published processing time for your exact application type, and note the date you submitted and received your acknowledgement of receipt.
  2. Use IRCC’s contact channels. Send a status request through your online account or the IRCC web form once the processing time has passed, and keep a copy of every message and reply with the dates.
  3. Ask for the file notes. A request under the Access to Information and Privacy Act (ATIP) for the officer’s notes (GCMS notes) can show whether the file is waiting on security checks, an officer, or something else. It takes time, so ask early.
  4. Send a written demand. A short, clear letter to IRCC stating your application number, how long you have waited and asking for a decision by a stated date shows that you asked and gives IRCC a chance to respond. Courts look for this.
  5. Consider your Member of Parliament. An MP’s office can sometimes raise a case with IRCC. It does not replace the steps above, and it does not stop you from going to court.

What goes into a mandamus application

The court needs evidence of the delay and of the harm it causes. Collect:

  • Your application number and the date you applied, with your acknowledgement of receipt.
  • The published processing time on the date you checked it, as a printout.
  • Every status request and reply, with dates.
  • Your written demand for a decision, and any response.
  • Evidence of the effect on you: a job offer that will expire, family separation, medical or school deadlines, an expiring permit.

What happens after you file

The application is filed with the court and served on the government. A judge decides whether to grant leave. If leave is granted, a hearing follows. In many delay cases, IRCC decides the application, or gives the court a timeline, after the application is filed, and the case is then discontinued or settled without a hearing. That outcome is not guaranteed. You also need to be ready for the decision to be a refusal, in which case the options in our guide to what to do after a refusal apply, and the short judicial review time limits start to run. You can check them with our free deadline calculator.

Time limits and acting promptly

The 15-day and 60-day limits for challenging a decision run from a decision. A delay is different because there is no decision to count from. Even so, courts expect you to act reasonably promptly once you decide to go to court, and waiting years while the situation worsens can weaken a case. If you are close to a deadline for something else, such as a permit that expires, say so when you ask for advice.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Applying to the court before the published processing time has passed.
  • Skipping the status requests and the written demand.
  • Sending many repeat messages that clog the file, or submitting duplicate applications.
  • Expecting the court to approve the application.
  • Believing anyone who promises that a court application guarantees approval.

Frequently asked questions

How long is too long to wait for IRCC?

There is no fixed number. Compare your wait with the published processing time for your application type. A wait well beyond it, with no good explanation, may support a court application.

Can the court order IRCC to approve my application?

No. It can order IRCC to make a decision. The decision can be an approval or a refusal.

Do I have to try other steps before going to court?

Courts expect you to have asked for a decision first. Status requests and a written demand are part of showing that, and they often resolve a file without court.

Does filing a court application hurt my immigration file?

Filing a mandamus application does not by itself count against you. The decision on your application is still made on its own merits.

Does a security check justify any length of delay?

No. The court gives IRCC more room when checks are genuinely under way, but the reason has to be specific, and the delay cannot continue without end.

Is there a time limit for filing?

The 15 and 60-day limits for challenging a refusal do not apply the same way because there is no decision. You should still act promptly, and tell your lawyer about any deadline that is coming up.

Is mandamus only for permanent residence?

No. It can apply to many kinds of applications, including work permits, study permits, sponsorship and citizenship, if the wait is long enough and unexplained.

Free 30-minute consultation

Waiting too long for a decision? Find out where you stand.

We will look at your timeline and the steps you have taken, and tell you whether a court application is realistic. Judicial review is available at an affordable flat fee, quoted in writing before you commit.

Book a free consultationSend us your details

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Immigration rules and court practice change, and your own file may differ. Written by Livingstone Law Professional Corporation, Toronto.

Legal Disclaimer: This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article does not create a solicitor-client relationship. Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results. This website does not constitute legal advice. A solicitor-client relationship requires a signed retainer agreement. For advice specific to your situation, please book a consultation.
Livingstone Law Professional Corporation

Ontario-regulated law firm acting in Immigration Law and 17 areas of law across the GTA. Dual-qualified in Canada and Nigeria.

Book Free Consultation →