Naghavi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1370
Federal Court | November 6, 2026 | Justice Battista | Docket IMM-17672-25
Result: judicial review and mandamus granted; a decision ordered within 90 days; no costs; no question certified.
What happened
Mr. Naghavi applied for permanent residence through the Start-up Visa program in March 2021, on the strength of a commitment from a designated organization. By June 2024, the file notes showed that the officer had found him eligible and not inadmissible, and that the application was ready to be finalized. It was not finalized, because two successive sets of ministerial instructions placed two other groups of start-up visa applicants ahead of him in the queue. Both instructions applied retroactively.
By the time of the hearing the application had been pending for about five and a half years. IRCC’s own estimate of the remaining time, 31 months, did not include the effect of the second set of instructions. He asked the Court for an order of mandamus, which requires an official to carry out a legal duty.
What the court decided
Justice Battista granted the application. Following the Federal Court of Appeal’s recent decision in Benison, he applied the usual mandamus requirements. The delay was longer than the nature of the process required: the Minister’s own communication treated a processing time of 37 months as too long for this program, and the applicant’s wait was far longer. The government appeared to accept this at the hearing.
The question then was whether the government had justified the delay. The Court accepted that ministerial instructions can justify a delay if they are made in good faith and are consistent with the Act. But here the instructions had pushed the applicant back twice, with no realistic estimate of when his file would be finished. The Court found that this was an open-ended delay, and that the instructions were the cause of it, not a justification for it. Treating the cause of the delay as its justification, the judge said, is circular reasoning.
The Minister argued that granting the order would undermine the instructions for everyone in the program. The Court disagreed. Mandamus is discretionary, each case turns on its facts, and another case with a stronger justification may come out differently. The Court ordered that a decision be made within 90 days. It did not order approval.
Our takeaway
This decision matters for anyone whose file is complete and waiting while newer files are moved ahead. The Court does not just ask how long you have waited. It asks whether the government can give a reason for the wait that has an end. A reason that has no end date is weak. It also helps to remember what the order does: it requires a decision, and the decision can still be a refusal. And this is one judge’s decision on one set of facts. A different judge, in a case about the same instructions, reached a different result on different reasoning.
What this means if you are in a similar situation
- Keep a timeline: when you applied, each request from IRCC, when you answered, and any note showing your file was ready for a decision.
- Keep copies of every status inquiry, with dates and the replies you received.
- Check IRCC’s published processing time for your program, and compare it with your own wait.
- Our guide to waiting too long for IRCC to decide explains when the Federal Court can order a decision.
- If you are refused, see our guide to what to do after a refusal, and check your dates with the deadline calculator. Judicial review time limits are generally 15 days if the decision was made in Canada and 60 days if it was made outside Canada.
Our advice, always: put your best foot forward
An immigration application is decided on what is in front of the officer. Include everything that supports it, explain anything that could raise a question, and do not count on being asked for more. If your file is ready and waiting, the record of what you did and when is what lets a court see the delay. Keep it from the first day.
Facing a similar problem with IRCC?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We will look at your situation and the deadlines.
Read the full decision on the Federal Court website.
This case note is our summary of a published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and it is not a substitute for reading the full decision. Every file is different.